To Polish or Not To Polish

To Polish or Not To Polish

Doreen is talking to a skull that she is holding in her right hand. No human is attached to the skull currently, and it looks like it's plastic. She is reciting "to Polish or not to Polish, that is the question" to the skull, but since this is a picture, you can't hear her. She is wearing a pink tshirt and glasses and she is in a yellow room. There is a bookshelf behind her that used to have sanitizing wipes that she forgot to remove before taking the picture, so we put fake books on the shelf instead to make it look like we did it on purpose.

That is the Question

There’s no indication in Shakespeare’s play whether or not Juliet ever considered painting her nails (although women sometimes did in her day[i]), but today, the debate on whether or not massage therapists should or should not rages on.

As you may know, I was VP of Ops for a very large massage franchise for about 15 years and we had a very strict “no nail polish, ever, under any circumstances” policy. Where I work now, there not only doesn’t seem to be a policy, but most therapists have fancy long (for a massage therapist) polished nails.

So, what’s right? Let’s look at science and a few studies done in related industries.

The Argument

The argument against polish for bodyworkers is that nail polish can harbor little nasties that you can transfer to your clients if you accidentally scratch them. Some even make the argument that your clients could have a reaction to the chemicals in your nail polish, although in my 20+ years, I’ve never heard anyone having one, so the risk is likely low.

The Science

What the research actually says is that fresh, intact nail polish has not been shown to raise infection rates. What does? The length of your nails.[ii]  A study found that nails longer than 2mm (that’s 0.0787 inches, or less than one tenth of an inch!) beyond the tip of the finger were the bigger contributor to high bacterial counts in the nails.

The chance of infection from an accidental nail scratch comes from whatever is on or under the nails at that moment. The risk of that happening with freshly painted (less than 4 days) short nails is about the same as a bare nail. In fact, one study found that 1-day-old polished nails had FEWER microorganisms than unpolished nails.[iii] Another found no difference in infections between surgical staff wearing nail polish and those who were not.[iv]

The Results Are In

At the end of the day, a massage therapist who works for someone else needs to follow their employers guidelines. If we know that freshly painted nails carry a slightly less risk than chipped polish or longer nails, your manager probably doesn’t have time for polish Inspections before every shift.

If you get to make the decision for yourself, or you work somewhere that allows polish, consider the following:

  • No matter the polish, keep your nails short, not beyond the tip of the finger.
  • If you are going to go the polish route, you are committing to ensuring your nail polish says fresh when you’re working on clients. 
    • This means putting fresh polish on your nails every four to five days.
    • Using higher quality polish will help keep your polish crack/chip free longer.
    • Applying a fresh topcoat BEFORE it gets chipped/cracked will reinforce the seal, restore the protective barrier, and protect the polish from oils and creams which can soften or dissolve polish.
    • Most infection control guidelines say that chipped polish needs to be removed fully. Slapping on a top coat and calling it a day doesn’t solve the issue, so if your nails aren’t surgery-ready, best to just remove it.
    • There are benefits to taking care of your nails twice a week, whether or not you polish them.
      • Tending to your nails, especially your nail bed, can keep your cuticles healthy. Torn cuticles are an avenue for YOU to catch the nasties from THEM.
      • If you are trimming your nails every few days, depending on how fast they grow, you can keep them short enough to not infect clients.
      • Your hands are your business! Keeping them healthy and looking great will give your clients confidence in your abilities!

    What’s your stance on polish? I’d love to hear your thoughts!

     


    [i] https://nailknowledge.org/blog/a-cultural-exploration-of-nail-technology-in-the-renaissance

    [ii] https://www.avma.org/javma-news/2018-05-01/study-finds-fingernail-length-not-nail-polish-increases-bacterial-counts

    [iii] https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/infection-control-and-hospital-epidemiology/article/nail-polish-used-by-healthcare-personnel-does-not-increase-the-rate-of-healthcareassociated-infections/8F422415D4CA49A5E9C5F69EC3668968

    [iv] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35938217/

    Cupping w/Silicone Cups in Killen, AL

    Bluewater Institute for Massage Therapy Commerce Way, Killen, AL, United States

    Bluewater Institute for Massage Therapy 23 Commerce Way, Killen, Alabama 35645 Friday, July 11, 2025 9a-5p Click here to register Killen, AL area massage therapists, enhance your massage  practice with our massage cupping course, designed specifically for professionals who want to add effective, high-impact techniques to their toolbox. This hands-on NCBTMB Certified 8 Hour continuing […]

    Tape It Easy in Killen, AL

    Bluewater Institute for Massage Therapy Commerce Way, Killen, AL, United States

    Class Canceled Due To Low Enrollment You can still register for Cupping with Silicone Cups on Friday, July 11, 2025 BLUEWATER Institute for Massage Therapy Commerce Way, Killen, AL 35645 Saturday, July 12, 2025 9a-5p Our kinesiology taping course is designed to help Killen, AL area massage therapists expand their skills with this versatile, dynamic […]

    Percussive Power in Killen, AL

    Bluewater Institute for Massage Therapy Commerce Way, Killen, AL, United States

    Class canceled due to low enrollment You can still register for 7/11  Cupping with Silicone Cups or 7/12 Tape it Easy BLUEWATER Institute for Massage Therapy Commerce Way, Killen, AL 35645 Sunday, July 13, 2025 10a-4p Killen, AL area therapists, enhance your massage therapy skills with our comprehensive NCBTMB certified 6 Hour continuing education course […]

    Tape It Easy in Southington, CT

    StrongHouse Studio 168 Center St #204, Southington, CT, United States

    Rescheduled from 5/14 StrongHouse Studio 168 Center St #204, Southington, CT 06489 Wednesday, July 16, 2025 9a-5p Click here to register Our kinesiology taping course is designed to help Hartford area massage therapists expand their skills with this versatile, dynamic tool. Kinesiology Tape, also known as KTape, can enhance your practice by improving mobility, reducing […]

    Tape It Easy in Somerset, NJ

    American Institute, Somerset, NJ 80 Cottontail Ln #103,, Somerset, NJ, United States

    American Institute – Somerset 80 Cottontail Ln #103, Somerset, NJ 08873 Monday, July 21, 2025 9a-5p Click here to register Our kinesiology taping course is designed to help Somerset, NJ area massage therapists expand their skills with this versatile, dynamic tool. Kinesiology Tape, also known as KTape, can enhance your practice by improving mobility, reducing […]

    Tape It Easy in Falls Church, VA

    Northern Virginia School of Therapeutic Massage 6402 Arlington Blvd #840, Falls Church, VA, United States

    Northern Virginia School of Therapeutic Massage 6402 Arlington Blvd #840, Falls Church, VA 22042 Friday, July 25, 2025 9a-5p Click here to register Our kinesiology taping course is designed to help Falls Church, VA area massage therapists expand their skills with this versatile, dynamic tool. Kinesiology Tape, also known as KTape, can enhance your practice […]

    Percussive Power in Bear, DE

    Academy of Massage and Bodywork 1218 Pulaski Hwy #324, Bear, DE, United States

    Academy of Massage and Bodywork 1218 Pulaski Hwy #324, Bear, DE 19701 Saturday July 26, 2025 9a-3p (Add Tape Yourself Seriously from 3p-6p for a 9-CE hour class) Click here to register  Bear area therapists, enhance your massage therapy skills with our comprehensive NCBTMB certified 6 Hour continuing education course focused on percussion massage gun […]

    Tape Yourself Seriously in Bear DE

    Academy of Massage and Bodywork 1218 Pulaski Hwy #324, Bear, DE, United States

    Academy of Massage and Bodywork 1218 Pulaski Hwy #324, Bear, DE 19701 Saturday, July 26, 2025 3p-6p (After Percussive Power, to make a 9-CE Class) Click here to register Why a KTape Self Care course? As a massage therapist, your body is your most important tool—but it’s also under constant stress. Repetitive motion, long hours, […]

    Thumb-Free Deep Tissue in Metuchen, NJ

    Academy of Natural Health Sciences 167 Main St # 2A, Metuchen, NJ, United States

    Academy of Natural Health Sciences Training Center 167 Main St # 2A, Metuchen, NJ 08840 Thursday, August 7, 2025 9a-5p Click here to register  (scroll to the middle of the page) Massage Therapist injury prevention isn’t just about what to avoid. This intermediate course will give Metuchen, NJ area therapists the tools they need to […]

    Tape It Easy in Exton, PA

    Wellness Institute of Chester County 402C Gordon Dr, Exton, PA, United States

    The Wellness Institute of Chester County 402C Gordon Dr, Exton, PA 19341 Friday, August 8, 2025 9a-5p Click here to register Our kinesiology taping course is designed to help Exton, PA area massage therapists expand their skills with this versatile, dynamic tool. Kinesiology Tape, also known as KTape, can enhance your practice by improving mobility, […]

    Thumb Free Deep Tissue in Bear, DE

    Academy of Massage and Bodywork 1218 Pulaski Hwy #324, Bear, DE, United States

    Rescheduled from 6/20 Academy of Massage and Bodywork 1218 Pulaski Hwy #324, Bear, DE 19701 Friday, August 8, 2025 9a-6p Massage Therapist injury prevention isn’t just about what to avoid. This NINE CE intermediate course will give Bear area therapists the tools they need to provide deep tissue massage without relying solely on our thumbs.  […]

    Percussive Power in Exton, PA

    Wellness Institute of Chester County 402C Gordon Dr, Exton, PA, United States

    The Wellness Institute of Chester County 402C Gordon Dr, Exton, PA 19341 Saturday, August 9, 2025 9am-3pm Click here to register Exton, PA area therapists, enhance your massage therapy skills with our comprehensive NCBTMB certified 6 Hour continuing education course focused on percussion massage gun techniques. This hands-on training explores the science and application of […]